Posts

Showing posts with the label biological determinism

Twin delusions

Image
Fascination with identical twins goes back a long way: think of the founders of Rome, Romulus and Remus, and the astrological symbol Gemini. Our modern understanding of genetics has given us a scientific perspective on identical twins, and yet it too is accompanied by a mythology. By virtue of being genetically identical, identical twins would seem to provide an ideal source of evidence concerning the heritability of traits. Since identical twins share physical characteristics, is it not conceivable that they also share traits such as intelligence and personality? There is, however, a fly in the ointment: the influence of the environment in which twins are raised. While eye colour has a purely genetic basis, couldn't intelligence depend on how twins are jointly brought up? There are two ways around this obstacle. Twins: Take 1 The first depends on a rather unlikely occurrence: identical twins separated at birth. Which brings us, my dear Watson (and Crick) to the curious case of Sir...

Nature vs. not sure

Image
The perennial nature-vs-nurture debate just won't go away. This is particularly true with regards to gender differences , a subject of broad interest. I'll acknowledge my biases up front. I have long been skeptical about biological determinism . This is partly because of its historical association with racism, sexism, classism, and the eugenics movement. But it's also because, particularly in recent years, there has been a tendency to overstate the importance of genetics in explaining human behaviour. Part of the explanation for this "genohype" may be the dramatic achievements of the Human Genome Project together with the rise of the biotechnology sector. Just as the success of Darwin's theory of natural selection led to Social Darwinism , today's molecular genetics revolution has put a new wind in the sails of biological determinism. In the scientific world, the nature-vs-nurture debate is generally accepted to be an ill-posed problem. Because the enviro...